In the fourth installment of our Critical Conditions podcast, Claire Berlinski and I tackled one of the grimmest weeks in memory. We discussed the shocking assassination of Charlie Kirk and what it says about America’s gun madness and polarization, NATO’s alarm over Russian drones breaching Polish airspace, and Israel’s audacious strike in Qatar that rattled alliances. It’s raw, unsparing, and worth your time.
The episode begins with the assassination of Charlie Kirk — a moment that forced both of us to grapple not just with political violence in America, but the deeper sickness of a society awash in guns. I pointed out the bitter irony that Kirk himself had defended high levels of gun violence as an acceptable cost of an armed citizenry. Claire reminded listeners that while we’ve seen assassinations before, never in modern U.S. history have we witnessed such a graphic, widely circulated killing. We worried aloud about what this does to a nation already fraying at the seams.
From there, we turned to NATO’s sudden awakening after Russian drones violated Polish airspace. Was this Putin testing the West yet again? We parsed whether the Alliance would show steel or mush — and the risks of Moscow concluding it can cross yet another red line without consequence.
Finally, we dove into Israel’s controversial strike in Qatar — a bold move against Hamas operatives that raised urgent questions. Could Israel really act without U.S. foreknowledge, given the giant American base there? Did Washington quietly green-light the operation, or was it a reckless gamble that could destabilize key relationships? We weighed the possibility of a strategic masterstroke against the dangers of burning bridges with an indispensable mediator.
The throughline is stark: a world where norms are shattered, violence metastasizes, and the risks of miscalculation grow daily.
For more, subscribe to Ask Questions Later.
